Writer’s Corner: The AI Controversy

Posted: October 5, 2026 | Author: kayelynnebooth | Filed under: AI Technology, Writer's Corner, Writing | Tags: AI Technology, book marketing, Kaye Lynne Booth, Writer's Corner, Writing, Writing to be Read |Leave a comment

I’ve always been one to stand on the middle ground in most things. “All things in moderation” is one of my mottos. And that’s how I was when it came to AI. I saw the value in some AI tools and I admittedly experimented with both AI and Generative AI tools a bit. I would use AI editing tools to polish each of my manuscripts. The AI tools often caught mistakes and errors that my familiar eyes might have otherwise missed. And I played with generative AI to stimulate my own imagination on my descriptions, occasionally. I also have four of my own books which I published in audiobook form with AI narration, but I don’t think I’ve sold even one audiobook, so I’m not sure how valuable that AI turned out to be. I have always been transparent about my use of AI, when I did use it, and I didn’t see the harm.

But now, it seems AI is being shoved down my throat. You may have heard this rant from me before, but it is true. (You can read that rant here: https://writingtoberead.com/2026/06/08/writers-corner-the-ai-delimma/)When I open an app, or email, I’m prompted to let copilot, or some other AI device, write it for me. And especially on my phone, I don’t seem to be able to get rid of it. The little box appears in my email suggesting I ‘polish’, and it won’t let me type myself as long as it is up. Now, I am a writer, and frankly, I find it insulting to think that I would need help from an AI tool to write an email, or anything else.

I know. There are people out there who want to let AI write the whole damned book for them, probably because they really can’t write themselves at all. And it’s true they are tarnishing the good names of those of us who can write, and making things more difficult, and more expensive, in the publishing world.

The AI Controversy

The controversy over AI has heated up in recent years, and at times seems to be out of hand. There are several different issues, including those mentioned above, which come up in author discussions about AI, and often get lumped together in the controversial category. Other issues include, but are in no way limited to, careers being damaged by the admitted use, or the championing of AI technology, copyrights being infringed upon by Generative AI’s unauthorized use of creative works and tying authors up in lengthy legal battles. These are all real concerns that should be taken into account as authors navigate the world of publishing.

What AI Can Do To An Author’s Career

Serepha Giron and the AI Witch Hunt

Horror author Serepha Giron, was recently outed from the Horror Writer’s Association just for speaking out in favor of the use of AI in some instances, calling the publishing industry’s over the top response to the use of AI in creative endeavors a witch hunt.

HWA Cancels Their Member Sèphera Girón After Pro-AI Newsletter Column Sparks Backlash

Chuck Wendig’s Response to the HWA’s Response

Regarding The Pro-AI Tantrum In The HWA Newsletter – Chuck Wendig: Terribleminds

Generative AI

Now, the other side of this debate involves a different matter involving generative AI specifically. There’s been quite a ruckus caused by the way generative AI is being trained using the words of talented authors without obtaining the proper permissions to do so. I know several authors whose works have been used for this purpose, and they are now tied up in a maze of legal battles over copyright and compensation. Authors on this side of the debate aren’t talking though. After the fiasco with the HWA and Seraph Giron, none of them would touch my invitation to guest post or comment here with a twenty-foot pole.

The most reasonable discussion I’ve found regarding this issue comes from Laura Hemling, The Guerrilla Publisher. She explains how generative AI works when used to write with the assistance of an AI tool, why not all generative AI training is not theft, or piracy, and why using AI tools to help write YOUR book doesn’t take away from YOUR authorship.

Just for the sake of transparency, let me go on record as stating that I use the MS Editor which is built into my MS Word program to locate possible problem spots, but then, I decide how to correct them, if I think they need correcting. Since AI is often wrong, I find it often doesn’t need fixed, or I have a better fix for it than the AI suggests. I no longer use Pro-Writing Aid, as its suggestions are mostly total rewording, which I don’t need, and neither do my authors.

I am going to have to rethink how I want to present my stance on AI, when it comes to collaborative works, because I don’t ask my authors about their AI use, so I can’t claim the WordCrafter Press books don’t use AI because I don’t really know. My feeling is to each his own, but I don’t want to make any false claims. I don’t want to be one of the publishers who tries to control their authors use of AI, as mentioned in the video, so perhaps just requesting them to notify me if AI was used so I can represent the work honestly would be the best way to go.

I would love to hear your thoughts on this. Do you use AI to assist in your writing? Use it just for editing? And if you do, are you forthcoming about it, or avoid mention of the topic? Let me know in the comments and let’s stir up a conversation.

___________________________

Now, be aware, the use of AI tools is not cut and dried. There are many different types of AI tools, and using an AI editor is not the same as using generative AI to write a book for you. And that is different than using generative AI to create a cover. And those are all different than the AI that helps us write or improve ads.

Other Uses for AI as an Author

AI is here to stay. It’s not going to go away, no matter what direction the controversy takes. It infiltrates almost every aspect of our lives today. We have it tied into our home systems, it’s at our fingertips on our phones, and now, it’s changing the way we find things on the internet. It’s writing books, narrating audiobooks, creating art and illustrations, and answering our queries.

It is embedded into the technology we’re already using. I didn’t want AI to summarize my emails, because I prefer to read them myself, and I don’t need it to write my emails for me. I find that insulting. So, I turned off the smart features in my gmail, as per Google instructions. To my chagrin, it didn’t just disable those two features, but also the sorting feature that divides my inbox into Primary, Updates, Social and other categories, making it easier to sort through. So, when I opened my inbox, instead of seeing my primary messages which I need to give attention, as usual, every message was bunched together in one big inbox, making them impossible to sort through. I had no idea that this was a smart feature, but apparently, if I want it, I’m stuck putting up with the features which I find so insulting.

I’m a writer. So, again, I would not use an AI tool to help me put words to page, (or write my emails). That’s what I do, so I think I will retain my creativity, although I may still use the editor which comes with MS Word.

But, I am not a cover designer or a marketer, so I might consider using AI tools to help me to complete such tasks. I see the value in using AI to carry out tasks that I don’t have the talent or the knowledge for. Is that wrong? I don’t think so. But I do think an author needs to be cautious in these tumultuous times, when any kind of association with AI could tarnish a good reputation, or even result in a death sentence. And if you are going to use AI, you need to be very transparent about it. You may lose some readers, but probably not as many as if you were not transparent and then get called out on it. I firmly believe it is better to state it up front.

We need to be aware though of what AI technology in these capacities entails. Using AI to create illustrations or book covers is truly an AI assist, because the technology creates the image according to what we, the humans feed it. We tell it we want an image of a girl, standing in a river and that’s what it gives us. Then, we tweak it to our own specifications. i.e. “a girl with red hair dressed in Native American attire”, etc… In fact, we are still the creators, because without our instruction, the AI can do nothing on it’s own. And I believe you can even provide the base image yourself and use AI to enhance it. It may take several attempts to get it right, because AI gets it wrong a lot, especially if you don’t know the right way to phrase your instructions so that AI understands.

Book Covers and Illustrations

I don’t use AI for the book covers I design, such as the ones shown above, but at times, I use a cover designer who does. DL Mullan of Undawnted, creates many of the WordCrafter Press book covers. Next March, when the third book in my Women in the West Adventure Series, Marta, is released through my Kickstarter campaign, I’m planning to offer special illustrated editions of all three books in the series, which Miss Mullan has created special covers for and she also is creating some spectacular illustrations, such as the girl in the water used in the example above, from Sarah, book 2.

Audiobook Narration

A few years ago, there was controversy about AI narration taking jobs away from human narrators. For me the point was mute, because I didn’t have the finances to afford a human narrator, I tried AI narration out on three of my books. The Rock Star & The Outlaw, Delilah and Hidden Secrets are all available in AI narrated audiobooks on Google Play Books, and another edition of The Rock Star & The Outlaw is also available on Apple Books. I put them all out there, although I admit I didn’t really know what I was doing, and I thought the quality of the AI narrations were fair. (I recently had the opportunity to review an AI narrated audiobook, Magnolia Bay Mystery: The Tainted Taffy, by Fiona Grace, (see my review here), and I would not have been able to tell the narrator was not human, had I not known.) But to be honest, that is as far as it went. I haven’t, to date, sold one copy. I don’t think I’ll be using AI narration any more in the future, as it just isn’t worth the effort.

If you are interested, you can check them out at the Google Play Books links below.

The Rock Star & The Outlaw: The Rock Star & The Outlaw: Time-Travel Adventure by Kaye Lynne Booth – Audiobooks on Google Play

Delilah: Delilah by Kaye Lynne Booth – Audiobooks on Google Play

Hidden Secrets: Hidden Secrets: Paranormal Mystery by Kaye Lynne Booth – Audiobooks on Google Play

(On a more exciting note, at least for me, I now may actually have a human narrator for both books in my Time Travel Adventure Series, The Rock Star & The Outlaw and Double Visions, and that tickles me purple. If all works out, those may be available as early nas 2028.)

Book Marketing

LinkedIn recently came out with a “New Guide: How to Dominate the AI Search on LinkedIn“, which may be aimed at B2B marketers, but the concept of writing to the AI Search might be useful in book marketing, as well, because AI Search is the new way readers are finding books.

The fact is, AI is changing the way our books are being discovered. The technology marches on, whether we jump into the procession or not. As things shift from browser to AI search, SEO is no longer the golden key which unlocks the door for readers to find our books. We may be writing books for our ideal readers, but it looks like we should be writing our book descriptions for AI recommendations, according to this article, “Make Your Books More AI Visible #Marketing”, by author and blogger Deborah Jay: https://deborahjayauthor.com/2026/08/17/make-your-books-more-ai-visible-marketing/

One Last Thought

One doesn’t have to be an author to worry about AI. If you want to ponder something that should scare the bejeesus out of you, check out Kim Kamando’s article, “Will AI be the End of the Human Race?“. This is some scary stuff, if you think about it.

About Kaye Lynne Booth

___________________________________________

Did you know you can sponsor your favorite blog series or even a single post with an advertisement for your book? Stop by the WtbR Sponsor Page and let me advertise your book, or you can make a donation to Writing to be Read for as little as a cup of coffee, If you’d like to show your support for this author and WordCrafter Press.

_____________________________________________

This segment of “Writer’s Corner” is sponsored by Undawnted.

Step Into the Undawnted Universe

Some authors write in one lane. DL Mullan builds worlds — and then dares you to walk into every single one of them.

Welcome to Undawnted, where imagination is fearless. Whether you’re craving a slow-burn paranormal romance, a bone-chilling horror story, a mind-bending sci-fi thriller, or songs/lyrical poetry that lingers long after the last line- there’s a feeling here waiting to pull you in.

Fall for the forbidden. In Nocturnal Redemption trilogy, mythology professor Ryan Blackburn has spent her life studying the legend of humanity’s protectors — never expecting to meet a pack of werewolves and a vampire on his nightly rounds. Her family’s myths weren’t myths at all. As she’s drawn into the vampire’s hidden world, one thing becomes clear:  no one is as they appear.

Fear what’s waiting in the woods. Kurst asks a simple, terrifying question: what could go wrong when you inherit a cabin in the woods? The answer involves a sasquatch, skinwalker, and medicine man — and readers have called it a masterclass in horror with “a good dark secret” at its heart. It’s part of the acclaimed Midnight Garden anthology, a dark fiction collection praised for delivering “the printed version of jump scares.”

Chase the multigenerational curse. Fans of atmospheric enigmas will want to dive into the Salt Pines Mystery series, where a family curse spans generations and secrets refuse to stay buried.

Go beyond the ordinary. In the sci-fi novelette The Reality Hackers, reality itself isn’t as constant as you think. And for readers who want an ongoing saga, DL Mullan’s multi-book Legacy Universe — a supernatural superhero series — is currently in the works, promising an expanding mythology for readers who like to get lost in a world for the long haul.

Need something lighter? The Town Santa Forgot brings warmth and holiday charm for readers who want romance with a side of magic, while DL Mullan’s poetry collections — including The Descent, Impetus, Effloresce, and Phantastic — offer a darker, Poe-and-Dickinson-inspired verse for poetry lovers who like their beauty a little haunted.

Why readers keep coming back: DL Mullan isn’t just a writer — she’s a classically trained musician, award-winning digital artist, and lifelong storyteller who designs her own book covers and builds entire creative universes around each release. That range shows: every story carries the fingerprints of someone who thinks in full sensory perception, not just plots.

Your next favorite book is waiting. Whether you want to be swept into romance, spooked by horror, hooked by mystery, or moved by poetry, Undawnted has a story with your name on it. New releases, exclusive updates, and giveaways are just a subscription away.

Visit www.undawnted.comto explore the growing library, read excerpts, listen to soundtracks, and find your next obsession.

SIgn up for the Undawntable Newsletter.

Like/Comment/Subscribe to Undawnted’s YouTube channel.

Undawnted: Read. Feel. Discover.

---